The 10 Best Custom Baseball Gloves, Tested And Researched

Jonathan Wilson By, Jonathan Wilson
Best Custom Baseball Gloves
Best Custom Baseball Gloves

The Rundown

1. Best Overall: Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove with Slow Pitch Pattern

"The Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove is designed for optimal performance, comfort and durability. The 14 inch Adult Glove is perfect for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball. Adjustable wrist strap allows for a customizable fit." Read Review

2. Best Bang For The Buck: Franklin Sports Unisex Adult 12.5-Inch Franklin Sports Baseball Glove

"Franklin Sports unisex baseball gloves provide a break in period of only one game and are designed to be ready to play out of the box. With a new, lightweight design, these gloves are perfect for any player looking to get back on the field without breaking in their glove." Read Review

3. Best Portable: Rawlings | Heart of The Hide Baseball Glove

"The Rawlings Heart of the Hide Youth-Size Glove is designed for infielders with low finger stalls to promote better contact with the back of the glove and give players more control when fielding. This 11.5 inch Pro I Web glove from Rawlings is contoured for a perfect pocket, and enhances your glove-to-throwing hand transfers." Read Review

4. Best Lightweight: EASTON FUTURE ELITE Youth Baseball Glove

"The EASTON Future Elite Youth Baseball Glove 11" is a right-handed glove with an open back and an easy, on-the-fly custom fit. The extended finger gussets give the player more control while using the pinkie loop allows for two fingers in the pinkie stall." Read Review

Baseball is a game of finesse and control. If you want to master the craft, get a pair of the best baseball gloves. Playing catch with your friends or hitting balls against the wall may not seem like much, but it helps you develop your hand-eye coordination, which is essential for batting, throwing, and catching.

Once you start playing regularly with your team or youth leagues, you’ll need a new set of gloves to keep pace. You might even want to upgrade from brands to top-notch ones that will last longer and fit better. We’ve developed this guide on the best custom baseball gloves available today.

You'll have an easier time deciding with our Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove with Slow Pitch Pattern recommendations. However, to provide the reader with a wider variety of alternatives, we recommend adding a Franklin Sports Unisex Adult 12.5-Inch Franklin Sports Baseball Glove if you are interested in purchasing another appealing one.

Here are the buying guides that we specially made for you guys. Follow all the words below for successful shopping!


FULL GRAIN LEATHER | Quality material ensures enhanced durability

ADJUSTABLE WRIST STRAP | Allows for a customizable fit for maximum comfort

14 INCH ADULT GLOVE | Perfect for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball

GAME READY FEEL | With quick, easy 80% factory - 20% player break-in process

ZERO SHOCK PALM PADDING | Provides increased impact protection while catching

BASKET WEB | Versatile web that can be used at any position on the field

TOP Choice #2 Franklin Sports Unisex Adult 12.5-Inch Franklin Sports Baseball Glove
Our Score:
Franklin Sports

ADJUSTABLE: The adjustable wrist strap provides a custom and versatile fit for all players

READY TO PLAY: This baseball glove is designed to be ready to play out of the box so you can skip the break in and hit the field.

VERSATILE: These gloves are perfect for baseball and softball and are designed to fit comfortably for adults and kids

DURABILITY CONSTRUCTION: These baseball gloves combine a premium cowhide palm with a PVC hybrid shell for premium durability to play season after season

LEFT HAND THROW: This glove is worn on the right hand for players who throw with their left hand

TOP Choice #3 Rawlings | Heart of The Hide Baseball Glove
Our Score:

LOWERED FINGER STALLS promote better contact with the back of the glove giving the player move control of their glove when fielding

DESIGNED FOR INFIELD PLAYERS, this Heart of the Hide 11.5 inch Pro I Web glove forms the perfect pocket and enhances your glove-to-throwing hand transfers

"FITS LIKE A GLOVE" the ContoUR series was designed as a result of extensive research and testing that revealed a need for a specific pattern tailored to smaller, thinner hands

ADJUSTABLE WRIST OPENING ContoUR gloves feature an adjustable wrist pull lace to allow players to create a custom, secure fit, creating better glove control

RIGHT HAND THROW (Glove goes on left hand)| 65% FACTORY/35% PLAYER BREAK-IN allowing for a faster break-in period, creating that game-ready feel

Right "Hand Orientation" Selection: Right Hand Throw & Glove on Your Left Hand

Ideal Fit System - Pro-style open back with an easy, on-the-fly, adjustable custom fit. Extended finger gussets for a more secure fit and better leverage. Re-positioned pinkie loop allows for two fingers in the pinkie stall

Left "Hand Orientation" Selection: Left Hand Throw & Glove on Your Right Hand

11" Youth pattern designed for the 11U player available in 12 colors to match player's uniform or glove color used by player's favorite pro player.

Game-ready Select Cowhide palm and web leather, durable genuine rawhide lace, and super soft palm lining

5 WILSON mens 11.5 Baseball Glove
Our Score:

DriLex Wrist Lining: Keeps your hand dry and comfortable on the field and behind the dish.

Bold Logos: Bold logos strip away the distractions, allowing outlined, eye-catching Wilson logos to announce a new era in the iconic story of the A2K and A2000.

Thin Heel Pad: A thin heel pad design allows for quicker break-in and better closure

Rolled Dual Welting: Dual Welting in Wilson gloves goes beyond a mere cosmetic effect, as it’s integrated into the liner of each infield, outfield and pitcher's model, offering better support and helping your glove hold its shape better over time.

H Web

Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

IDEAL FOR AVID PLAYERS FROM HIGH SCHOOL TO THE PROS, this glove features full-grain kip leather that provides an unmatched look and feel

PRO GRADE leather laces add durability and strength, and padded thumb sleeve adds comfort

100% WOOL PADDING helps with pocket formation and to retain the glove's shape, and PITTARDS SHEEPSKIN PALM LINING keeps your hand dry and comfortable

30% FACTORY / 70% PLAYER BREAK-IN allows player to complete the majority of the break-in process, so that the fit is exactly to their needs

DESIGNED FOR OUTFIELD PLAYERS, this Pro Preferred 12. 75 inch Trap Eze Web baseball glove will give you the confidence on the field to catch any fly ball hit your way

PITTARDS SHEEPSKIN PALM LINING keeps your hand dry and comfortable

PRO GRADE leather laces add durability and strength, and padded thumb sleeve adds comfort

✅ High quality pigskins leather.

✅ Comfortable with very soft inside.

✅ Foldings, closed pocket, palm reinforcement.

8 SHOELESS JOE Golden Era 1910 Fielders Baseball Glove
Our Score:
Shoeless Joe Ballgloves

FEATURES - Individually hand-cut and sewn, keeps its shape and structure for many seasons

MODEL – 1910 Golden Era Fielder’s glove is a reproduction glove from the first half century of baseball

FIT - Left-Hand Throw (Item goes on the right hand), Right-Hand Throw (Item goes on the left hand)

MATERIAL & DESIGN - Special aged soft antique tobacco leather sewn using the original patterns and components of a particular time period

INTENDED FOR - Professional break-in process, experience the baseball game in past years

9 SHOELESS JOE 12 1/2 Proffessional Series 6 Finger Baseball Glove
Our Score:
Shoeless Joe Ballgloves

100% Leather

Reconditioning Program Available

Field Ready - Little to NO Break-In Time


Handmade Custom Personalized Embroidered Glove

Recommended for ages 9 and up

Gold/Yellow Thread - Script Font

Allow 4-5 Weeks for Delivery

Once a custom/personalized order is submitted, it cannot be modified or cancelled.

Limit 20 Characters (including spaces)

There will be NO returns or exchanges of customized/personalized merchandise unless merchandise is defective or customized incorrectly.

What to Look For in a best custom baseball gloves?

Is it necessary for you to purchase best custom baseball gloves in 2024 from Amazon within the next few hours? Perhaps you've just learned about something which can benefit friends or family members but aren't sure where to turn or who to trust.

So, we're here to help. Our new article will show you how to purchase the best item for your necessities quickly so that it arrives on time and as expected. It's that easy!

Wrist Adjustments

A few gloves feature wrist adjustments. They allow players to tailor the glove to their needs, making it easy to take on and off. Velcro, a buckle and a D ring are all possible.


It is also important to think about your preferred padding. Based on what position you play, the padding on your glove will vary. The padding in the catcher's glove is more to shield their hands against pitcher's throws. Some positions may need additional padding, like third base and first base. The popularity of additional wrist padding, especially in corner-infield positions, has increased recently.


Bad fitting gloves can distract and make you uncomfortable. It is crucial to find the perfect fit. The size of the glove that you will need depends on where you play. The glove size of outfielders is usually greater than that of infielders.


You can find different kinds of webbing in gloves made for softball and baseball players. For infielders, the most popular type of webbing is looser. This gives you more control to get the ball out quickly and doesn't collect large amounts of dirt. Gloves with open webs will be preferred by infielders to provide visibility while protecting the sun.


The needs of every player are different so baseball gloves have a variety of styles. Baseball gloves can have huge differences in design. First baseman need to have more surface for contact with the ball and outfielder must have more. Your position will dictate the size of your glove to best fit your actions on the field.


Many materials can be used in gloves. These include leather, synthetic material, mesh and treated leather. Players prefer leather for its strength and durability. Pre-conditioned oil can be added to treated leather gloves for an easier break-in. Many prefer the lighter mesh-backed glove. The synthetic glove, which is lightest and cost-effective for players younger than adult size, works great.

Backs Of A Glove

The open and closed-back gloves are available to players. On the glove's backside, this portion can be seen above the wrist. If you have an open back, there will be a small space between the wrist and your back. While this is personal preference, there are some backs that work better in certain positions.


How Do You Clean A Baseball Glove?

It can be quite delicate to clean a baseball glove if it is done properly. A simple wipe with your hands can be used to remove dirt from the glove. Use soap and water sparingly. Don't wash the glove with soap or use water as this can dry out leather and cause it to turn crusty.
Once you have finished cleaning the gloves you can apply leather conditioner to your hands.

What's The Difference Between Right-hand Thrower Vs Left-hand Thrower?

A left-handed person would use the glove on their right-hand. For right-handed people, they will need the glove on their left. The left-hand thrower will be more rare than the right-hand one.

How Do I Get My New Glove In Place?

There are many methods you can use to get your glove in shape. Your glove will only be as good as the time it takes to get used to. The more leather you have, the easier it is to break in.

Which Size Glove Should You Get?

Because of their slower reaction times, infielders tend to wear smaller gloves that are easier to control. Because infielders use smaller gloves, they are able to get the ball out faster and throw out runners. Outfielder gloves tend to be larger and have deeper pockets because they chase down fly balls. A bigger mitt also helps reduce the distance from the ball.

How Do You Break In A Baseball Gloves?

Many baseball gloves come soft and ready to use, however, if you choose a premium leather glove, it will likely need some breaking in.

How Do You Size A Baseball Glove?

It is important to consider the positions you play and personal preferences when choosing the right size baseball glove. Iannarilli stated that size is determined by preference. He also stated that the size of a glove varies depending on its position. For example, infielders will prefer gloves between 11.25 to 11.75 inches. While outfielders may favor gloves up to 12.5 inches.

What Should A Baseball Glove Look Like?

You should find a baseball glove that fits comfortably but is not too tight on your hand. So that you don't have any extra hands, the glove must stop about halfway between your thumb and your finger. But if you feel the glove falling off your fingers or it feels too tight, it may be a sign that the glove is not fitting correctly.


Its features, not its name, are what define best custom baseball gloves in 2024. This may seem self-evident, but it's easy to become fixated on a specific company or brand due to its reputation. We strongly advise you to consider your needs and determine which products will assist you in meeting them. With our options above, if you can't choose any suitable one, let's check Shoeless Joe Gloves Handmade Custom Personalized 12-Inch Basket Web Baseball Glove. Wish you a nice shopping day!

0 ratings

About Jonathan Wilson

Jonathan Wilson

Jonathan Wilson is a former pro football player and tech reporter who now serves as the editor of Kris Van Assche's website. He is a dedicated fitness enthusiast who splits his workout time between strength and conditioning training, martial arts and running.

Jonathan's athletic career began in college, where he was a star running back. He went on to play professionally for several years before injuries forced him to retire. Afterward, Jonathan transitioned into a career in tech reporting, where he quickly made a name for himself as a knowledgeable and insightful commentator on the industry.

In addition to his work with our website, Jonathan remains active in the world of sports. He regularly competes in martial arts tournaments and running events, and he is always looking for new ways to challenge himself physically. Jonathan is an inspiration to many people, and he is proof that it is never too late to pursue your passions.

Read Jonathan's full bio