The 10 Best Baseball Mitts Of 2024, Tested By Our Experts

Jonathan Wilson By, Jonathan Wilson
Updated
Best Baseball Mitts
Best Baseball Mitts

The Rundown

1. Best Overall: Rawlings Player Preferred, Regular Baseball Glove

"The Rawlings Player Preferred baseball glove is designed for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball players. The revolutionary new glove design is a result of input from more than 6,000 current college and high school players. The gloves feature a T-web, which allows the wristers to move naturally with the ball, leading to increased performance in the field." Read Review

2. Best For The Price: WILSON 2021 A360 Youth Baseball Glove

"This mitt is designed with a low-profile wrist strap to keep your hand in place and make it easier to catch balls in front of you, and a Full Cap Leather Palm for durability and comfort throughout the game." Read Review

3. Best Comfortable: Rawlings unisex adult First Rawlings Renegade

"The Rawlings unisex adult Renegade 12 baseball glove is the perfect First Rawlings baseball glove for recreational players. The lightweight, soft and supple leather features Moisture-wicking technology to keep you cool and dry." Read Review

4. Best Versatile: Hit Run Steal Baseball Glove

"Hit Run Steal brings you baseball gloves that are tough, durable and have a classic design. The All American gloves are made from 100% cowhide leather so they will last longer. They feature a tight, clean seam to prevent frays and tears, and are designed for both left-handed as well as right-handed players." Read Review

You might not know it, but your hands play a huge role in your ability to catch and throw the ball. Whether you enjoy playing baseball or just need something fun to do on rainy days, having the right mitt can make all the difference. When choosing the right mitt, there are plenty of things you should consider.

Are you a power hitter? Do you prefer a mitt that’s more flexible or one that grips better? Are you looking for a lightweight option or one that doesn’t make your hands sweat? Whatever your need, we’ve got an answer for you. In this article, we take an in-depth look at our favorite baseball mitts so you can find the perfect fit as well.

After nearly 18 hours of research, We think the best baseball mitts is Rawlings Player Preferred, Regular Baseball Glove. Or you can check the WILSON 2021 A360 Youth Baseball Glove as the other great option, even if the first option didn't meet all of your requirements.

Compare

TOP Choice #1 Rawlings Player Preferred, Regular Baseball Glove
Our Score:
9.9
Rawlings

12 1/2 INCH ADULT GLOVE | Perfect for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball

ZERO SHOCK PALM PADDING | Provides increased impact protection while catching

GAME READY FEEL | With quick, easy 80% factory - 20% player break-in process

ADJUSTABLE WRIST STRAP | Allows for a customizable fit for maximum comfort

FULL GRAIN LEATHER | Quality material ensures enhanced durability

BASKET WEB | Versatile web that can be used at any position on the field

TOP Choice #2 WILSON 2021 A360 Youth Baseball Glove
Our Score:
9.7
WILSON

Black/Grey leather in a timeless look

Half Moon Web

31.5"

Velcro design for easy in-game adjustments

CarbonLite Shell helps reduce the weight without sacrificing durability

TOP Choice #3 Rawlings unisex adult First Rawlings Renegade
Our Score:
9.5
Rawlings

Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Lightweight Pro mesh back design.Lining: Pro Micro

Durable leather shell palm construction

Deep, flexible pocket is ideal for Baseball or Softball

High-density cushioned palm and index finger pads

Game-ready feel right off the shelf

4 Hit Run Steal Baseball Glove
Our Score:
9.3
Hit Run Steal

All American baseball glove adult and youth 11.5 inch is designed for right handed baseball players of all ages. Suitable for palm sizes of up to 10 inches

Hit Run Steal Men's Baseball Glove is made of high quality, American barnstormer leather crafted from American steerhide with a full grain leather palm lining and dual palm construction for maximum comfort, pocket consistency, and durability.

HRS All American Baseball Glove are made of high quality light weight material, allowing for a faster and easier break in.

All gloves are laced with high quality USA leather laces for every baseball glove.

HRS Baseball Mitt uses a 100% wool blend padding for a more consistent and undeviating pattern shape, improved durability and reduced shock from hard ball impact.

Butter soft palm liner: PU palm lining for increased durability, feel, and comfort

Right Hand Throw= worn on left hand, left hand Throw= worn on right hand

Full grain pigskin leather: for great durability

Mzo lining: disperses perspiration away from the skin

Right Hand Throw = Left Hand Glove, Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove

12 inch all leather youth baseball glove styled after Bryce Harper's game model

Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Pro H web with all leather lacing ideal for use in the outfield

Youth Pro Taper Fit pattern offers a Smaller hand opening for greater Control

Palm and index finger padding with cushioned fingerback lining

Game Ready; comes 90percentage broken in from the factory

Designed for the game’s young talent, the 2022 A450 lineup delivers the perfect fit for small hands and the lightest all-leather glove on the market. Top Grain leather is ready to play, and the Quick Fit elastic wrist is designed to securely fit small hands for ages 7 and under.

10.75"

Quick Fit Wrist

Position: Infield

H Web

FAST PLAY: Specially treated to go from the store to the playing field with no break-in required

SIZE: 13" ; Outfield ; Basket Web design for extra glove flexibility

ADJUSTABLE: The adjustable wrist strap provides a custom and versatile fit

VERSATILE: These gloves are perfect for baseball, softball, and t-ball play

DURABILITY: These baseball gloves combine a premium cowhide palm with a PU-Laminated PVC hybrid shell

GAME READY: Sandlot gloves arrive 80 percent broken-in from the factory

12.75 in. OUTFIELD, PRO H WEB - great for use in both baseball and softball

PADDED FINGER BACK LININGS for unmatched comfort

ZERO SHOCK PALM PADS for extra protection

FULL-GRAIN OILED SHELL LEATHER for added durability

ALWAYS THE BEST: Rawlings is a front-runner in baseball gear and innovation trusted by professionals everywhere, so buying Rawlings gear is a commitment to being the best.

EXTRA COMFORT: Padded fingerback liners and a youth pro taper fit designed for players of any position and skill level.

Department name: Boys

80% FACTORY BROKEN IN: This glove is playable right out of the box with minimum break-in required.

NEXT-LEVEL BASEBALL PERFORMANCE: This R9 glove comes with a soft, durable & All-Leather Shell that’s both a premium build and comfortable wear.

SIZED FOR YOU: The players series keeps the players in mind, with a strategic design to be as good-fitting and comfortable as possible.

A Simple Way To Choose The best baseball mitts For You

Would you like to know how to select the best baseball mitts to purchase in 2024? We have a straightforward solution for you. First, consider your own requirements. For instance, should you need something that could be used during workouts, look for products that are made of high-quality materials and are resistant to water.

Consider the price range next. Some people prefer low prices, while others prefer to invest additional money on better quality items, so weigh both choices once making a decision.

Eventually, reading reviews is a simple way to select the best baseball mitts to buy. Please read our research below before purchasing anything and follow that guide to select your best baseball mitts.

Webbing

You can find different kinds of webbing in gloves made for softball and baseball players. For infielders, the most popular type of webbing is looser. This gives you more control to get the ball out quickly and doesn't collect large amounts of dirt. Gloves with open webs will be preferred by infielders to provide visibility while protecting the sun.

Backs Of A Glove

The open and closed-back gloves are available to players. On the glove's backside, this portion can be seen above the wrist. If you have an open back, there will be a small space between the wrist and your back. While this is personal preference, there are some backs that work better in certain positions.

Wrist Adjustments

A few gloves feature wrist adjustments. They allow players to tailor the glove to their needs, making it easy to take on and off. Velcro, a buckle and a D ring are all possible.

Padding

It is also important to think about your preferred padding. Based on what position you play, the padding on your glove will vary. The padding in the catcher's glove is more to shield their hands against pitcher's throws. Some positions may need additional padding, like third base and first base. The popularity of additional wrist padding, especially in corner-infield positions, has increased recently.

Size

Bad fitting gloves can distract and make you uncomfortable. It is crucial to find the perfect fit. The size of the glove that you will need depends on where you play. The glove size of outfielders is usually greater than that of infielders.

Material

Many materials can be used in gloves. These include leather, synthetic material, mesh and treated leather. Players prefer leather for its strength and durability. Pre-conditioned oil can be added to treated leather gloves for an easier break-in. Many prefer the lighter mesh-backed glove. The synthetic glove, which is lightest and cost-effective for players younger than adult size, works great.

Position

The needs of every player are different so baseball gloves have a variety of styles. Baseball gloves can have huge differences in design. First baseman need to have more surface for contact with the ball and outfielder must have more. Your position will dictate the size of your glove to best fit your actions on the field.

FAQs

How Do You Break In A Baseball Gloves?

Many baseball gloves come soft and ready to use, however, if you choose a premium leather glove, it will likely need some breaking in.

How Do You Size A Baseball Glove?

It is important to consider the positions you play and personal preferences when choosing the right size baseball glove. Iannarilli stated that size is determined by preference. He also stated that the size of a glove varies depending on its position. For example, infielders will prefer gloves between 11.25 to 11.75 inches. While outfielders may favor gloves up to 12.5 inches.

How Do You Clean A Baseball Glove?

It can be quite delicate to clean a baseball glove if it is done properly. A simple wipe with your hands can be used to remove dirt from the glove. Use soap and water sparingly. Don't wash the glove with soap or use water as this can dry out leather and cause it to turn crusty.
Once you have finished cleaning the gloves you can apply leather conditioner to your hands.

Which Size Glove Should You Get?

Because of their slower reaction times, infielders tend to wear smaller gloves that are easier to control. Because infielders use smaller gloves, they are able to get the ball out faster and throw out runners. Outfielder gloves tend to be larger and have deeper pockets because they chase down fly balls. A bigger mitt also helps reduce the distance from the ball.

What's The Difference Between Right-hand Thrower Vs Left-hand Thrower?

A left-handed person would use the glove on their right-hand. For right-handed people, they will need the glove on their left. The left-hand thrower will be more rare than the right-hand one.

How Do I Get My New Glove In Place?

There are many methods you can use to get your glove in shape. Your glove will only be as good as the time it takes to get used to. The more leather you have, the easier it is to break in.

What Should A Baseball Glove Look Like?

You should find a baseball glove that fits comfortably but is not too tight on your hand. So that you don't have any extra hands, the glove must stop about halfway between your thumb and your finger. But if you feel the glove falling off your fingers or it feels too tight, it may be a sign that the glove is not fitting correctly.

Conclusion

We hope this blog has provided you with useful information about selecting the best baseball mitts to buy. If you're still unsure, consider why you're purchasing a product in the first place.

Here you can select the Marucci boys Right Hand Thrower Baseball Glove if you are unable to select one of the available items above. Consider whether any of our suggestions aided you in deciding which products to purchase. Please do not hesitate to contact us at any time!


2 ratings

About Jonathan Wilson

Jonathan Wilson

Jonathan Wilson is a former pro football player and tech reporter who now serves as the editor of Kris Van Assche's website. He is a dedicated fitness enthusiast who splits his workout time between strength and conditioning training, martial arts and running.

Jonathan's athletic career began in college, where he was a star running back. He went on to play professionally for several years before injuries forced him to retire. Afterward, Jonathan transitioned into a career in tech reporting, where he quickly made a name for himself as a knowledgeable and insightful commentator on the industry.

In addition to his work with our website, Jonathan remains active in the world of sports. He regularly competes in martial arts tournaments and running events, and he is always looking for new ways to challenge himself physically. Jonathan is an inspiration to many people, and he is proof that it is never too late to pursue your passions.

Read Jonathan's full bio